Manindra Nath Thakur, Jawaharlal Nehru University
One fine morning, I dropped into my room at the Centre for Political Studies, JNU.
Monika took an appointment to meet and discuss her project. I was curious to know
about her work and wanted to see if there was anything to learn from it. Within no time,
I discovered that she was influenced by a professor and that we had many common
concerns. I listened carefully and was convinced by her impression. We decided to
initiate a conversation. Suddenly, a few months later, she informed me about Liah
Greenfeld’s sad demise. Our conversation could not take off.
There are some scholars whom you meet and never forget. There are others whom one
never gets an opportunity to meet, yet whose ideas enter one’s intellectual world with
such intensity that they become part of the future conversations in absentia. Professor
Liah Greenfeld belongs to the latter category for me. Monika shared some of her
writings, and I discovered striking convergences between her work and the questions a
group of us in India has been pursuing in the Creative Theory Colloquium. We had
begun contemplating a larger civilizational conversation that could bring together
different intellectual traditions and modes of understanding humanity.
The news of her passing away came as a blow to our plans. However, some
conversations do not end with death. Indeed, the most significant conversations in
human history often begin after the physical departure of those who initiate them. If
civilization itself is a cumulative dialogue across generations, then the death of a thinker
does not close a discussion. In this case, I believe, it should begin the discussion. The
shift of location is inevitable — from direct exchange to engagement through texts,
ideas, memoirs, and communities of scholars. Despite not being able to converse with
her directly, I felt it was worth documenting her influence on our thinking to initiate a
new chapter in the dialogue. I would like to acknowledge her presence in the memory
of the members of the Creative Theory Group who enjoy discussing her writings.
Civilizational Dialogue and Emergentist Universals
What first attracted me to Greenfeld’s work was her attempt to recover the concept of
civilization as a serious analytical category. For several decades, the language of
civilization has often been viewed with suspicion. It was associated either with
triumphalist narratives of the West or with simplistic theories of cultural conflict.
Greenfeld approached the idea differently. Instead of ranking civilizations, it invited
us to address the question of differences in civilization. It is no longer a question of judging a civilization as good or bad. She appreciated the differences in civilizations and suggested exploring the reasons for these differences and developing a theory to understand them.
For many of us interested in the project of decolonization, this has opened new
possibilities. We found her approach closer to what we were suggesting about the
civilizational uniqueness of India and the need to explore the specificity of Indian
Political Theory. In contrast to the claim that political theory is universal, we suggest
that every civilization has unique experiences and that it is necessary to consider
different ways to develop theories grounded in this uniqueness. It does not mean that
there has to be civilizational relativism. It only means that the universal has to be
contested, and we need to reopen the accepted universals, since most of the time they
are based on the experiences of a single civilization. We need to keep the idea of the
universal open and consider it always emerging through civilizational dialogue.
Her argument that civilizations are structured symbolic universes organized around
foundational principles offers a big-picture perspective. These principles shape modes
of thought, moral orientations, emotional dispositions, institutions, and historical
trajectories. In her understanding, civilizations are not external containers within which
people live. They are cognitive and moral worlds that shape how reality itself is
experienced.
She suggests that there are three kinds of civilizations coexisting in the world today: the
monotheistic, the Sinic, and the Indic. These civilizations may differ in the level of the
individual mind — cognitive (about the structure and contents of thought), moral, and
emotional — and in the levels of society (separate institutions and institutional systems)
and history. The project helps us understand the fundamentals of these civilizations.
Greenfeld’s framework suggests that the deepest foundations of a civilization lie in its
mode of thought. This mode of thought shapes its concepts and values, which in turn
influence psychological dynamics and eventually crystallize into institutions and
patterns of historical development. She does not claim that influence moves only in
one direction. She explicitly suggests that there are feedback loops: new institutions
can change values, new values can reshape emotions, and social change can alter
concepts. However, she suggests that the first principles and mode of thought remain
relatively stable and continue to set limits on what kinds of changes are possible.
This idea of Greenfeld would make sense to anyone observing a postcolonial society,
such as India. There is a civilizational mode of thought within which colonialism has
brought some changes. It would be a mistake to think that everything has changed or
that nothing has changed. One of the projects the Creative Theory Group is involved
in is mapping knowledge and practice in the Indian subcontinent. The idea is to see
how this civilizational society has responded to the advent of Western modernity.
Our research suggests that civilizational continuity comes from what Greenfeld has
called the first principle and the mode of thought. In a village that nurtured the Nyaya
philosophy, one of the six Indian philosophies, the mode of thinking is still guided by
its basic elements. The Darshana continues to guide the achar and vyavahar. However,
simultaneously, there is an impact of modernity and new institutions. Greenfeld’s
suggestion is quite convincing: civilizations are not merely collections of rituals or
customs; instead, they have deep structures of meaning. She is right in arguing that the
foundational principles of civilizations shape characteristic ways of thinking, feeling,
and organizing collective life, and these patterns persist for centuries even while
institutions and historical circumstances change,
Monotheistic Civilization vs Indic Civilization
Her analysis of the monotheistic civilization suggests that the foundational principle of
one universal God generated a distinctive mode of logical thought and a particular
sensitivity to contradiction. From this emerged concepts such as truth, justice,
individuality, responsibility, and freedom. One may disagree with the proposition;
however, it is remarkable that she sought to explore the organizing principles of
civilizations and to connect all the elements to these basic principles. This is an
interesting insight, as it explains why political theory in this civilization is based on a
concept of human nature that remains, for the most part, unidimensional. The idea of
methodological individualism among social contract theorists begins with a
unidimensional understanding of human nature and develops a full-blown political
theory based on this idea.
Greenfeld’s framework invites us to examine Indic civilization from its foundational
principles. Unlike the monotheistic civilization, which is organized around the idea of
one God and a unified conception of reality, the Indic tradition encompasses a plurality
of gods, texts, philosophical perspectives, and paths to truth, raising important questions
about its characteristic mode of thought and civilizational logic. One of the
foundational principles of this civilization has been the conceptualization of human
beings as more complex than in the monotheistic perspective.

One of the most widely shared understandings of human nature in Indian philosophical
traditions, as reflected in both classical texts and popular common sense, is that human
beings are constituted by ten fundamental characteristics: the four purushartha and the
six vikars. The first purusharth is Artha, which relates to the human engagement with
the material world and nature; the second is kama, which refers to human desire arising
from our biological existence; the third is dharma, which refers to the laws of nature as
well as the moral and social principles derived from an understanding of those laws;
and moksha points to the capacity for self-awareness and the consciousness of
consciousness itself.
Together, these categories offer a more complex and multidimensional understanding
of the human person than many modern theories of human nature. The relative presence
and interaction of these vary among individuals and across different contexts. As the
proposition changes over time and space, they share distinct personalities and modes of
being, making nature a dynamic rather than a fixed reality.
The complexity in the idea of human nature is only one example of the implications of
Greenfeld’s theory of civilizations. For several years, many of us associated with the
Creative Theory Group have been exploring concepts, categories, and intellectual
traditions emerging from Indian experiences. We have been asking whether categories
such as dharma, moksha, karuna, swaraj, lokasangraha, shrama, and sah-astitva
represent merely local cultural expressions or whether they contain broader theoretical
possibilities relevant to humanity as a whole.
Initiating a Civilizational Dialogue
Greenfeld’s project offered an important opportunity. Rather than forcing Indic
traditions into conceptual frameworks derived elsewhere, her approach appeared to
create space for understanding civilizations on their own terms. Such a framework
could potentially open a new stage in comparative political theory and civilizational
studies. At the same time, engagement with Greenfeld’s work would necessarily
involve critical dialogue. Her characterization of monotheistic, Sinic, and Indic
civilizations raises many questions. Such a dialogue throws several questions for the
Creative Theory Group: Does the Indic tradition possess a single foundational
principle? How should one understand the coexistence of apparently contradictory
philosophical positions within Indian intellectual history? Can categories developed
from the study of one civilization adequately illuminate another? What is the
relationship between logic and non-dual forms of thinking? These are not objections to
her work; rather, they are precisely the questions that make dialogue fruitful.
In many ways, Greenfeld’s project resonates with the Indian tradition of debate among
Buddhist, Naiyayikas, Mimamsakas, Vedantins, Jains, and others. This tradition asserts
that knowledge advances not through isolation but through sustained engagement with
differences. Differences provide an opportunity to think through others, which
illuminates the self, too. Reading Greenfeld, one senses a similar aspiration operating
at the level of civilizations. She was inviting scholars to move beyond superficial
multiculturalism and engage the foundational assumptions that shape different
civilizational worlds. Such an undertaking is difficult because it demands both
intellectual confidence and intellectual humility. One must deeply understand one’s
own tradition while remaining open to learning from others.
In short, we need to appreciate her understanding of the continuity of intellectual life
beyond physical experience. Some scholars, teachers, and friends live with us forever,
becoming etched in the brain cells that support the life of our mind; they become part
of our being. This is how intellectual relationships become part of one’s inner world.
What makes her passing particularly poignant is that she herself understood the
continuity of intellectual life beyond physical existence. We must continue her work,
and this is the best way to remember Liah Greenfeld.
Thakur, Manindra Nath (2026) “Liah Greenfeld and Civilizational Dialogue: For Continuing a Legacy,”
Comparative Civilizations Review: Vol. 95: No. 95, Article 16.
Available at: https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/ccr/vol95/iss95/16