Teaching About Antisemitism and Antizionism

In 2016, Liah Greenfeld submitted a proposal to the Israel Institute (and received one of its faculty development grants), for the development of a course titled “A Democracy in the Middle East: Israel as a Case for Comparative Analysis.”  She taught the course at Boston University from 2018 to 2024. 

in the first 9 weeks or so of the class, Liah presented and discussed with the students facts about Israel and the Arab-Israeli conflict. The balance of the course was dedicated to students’ presentations on specific relevant topics they researched.

A Boston University student, Alex Wecht, responding to the rise in open antisemitism and antizionism after October 7, wrote in the Pittsburgh Jewish Chronicle:

I was lucky to come into contact with one of a minority of faculty members at Boston University seeking to combat this open Jew-hatred. Liah Greenfeld, an authority in interdisciplinary social sciences, especially nationalism, and a professor at Boston University, teaches a class on Israel and antisemitism. For this course, she developed a comprehensive explanation based on the systematic examination of facts, which allowed me and 20-some classmates to truly understand the problem that Jews, and our civilization, are facing.

Greenfield stresses that there are no antisemitic traditions in the Chinese and Indian civilizations and connects antisemitism to monotheism — which is the essence and source of our civilization — and specifically to the fact that the foundations of both Christianity and Islam are borrowed from the Jews. The scriptures and history of these two religions show that, since their inception, they have been fixated on the Jews, whom they envy because God revealed Himself to the Jews first. For thousands of years, their leaders invented Jew-hating tropes and infused them in popular consciousness. These tropes of Jew-hatred, perpetuated for more than 2000 years and conveniently molding to the trendy ideology of the times, made antisemitism the most institutionalized, systemic attitude in our Western, monotheistic civilization. It is an irrational hatred and cannot ever be explained by rational grievances (for instance, accusations of “white colonialism” or “apartheid”): All such grievances are invented, based not on fact but on the deep complex of inferiority that, through various tropes, has been sewn into collective identities, deeply cut into the mind of the West.

This rare course made today’s otherwise unbelievable prevalence and appeasement of antisemitism understandable. With the institutionalized tropes, laid out in Christian and Muslim traditions and later ingrained into the secular social consciousness of nations, modern antisemitism and damnatory claims about Jews and Israel are easily appeased, accepted and parroted.

The course syllabus, Spring 2024:

Israel in Comparative Perspective: A Democratic Society in the Middle East

Spring 2024

Professor Liah Greenfeld

Course Description:

The most controversial society in the world from its foundation in 1948, judging by the amount and nature of coverage it attracts in the media and discussion in international bodies such as the UN, Israel is eminently suited to the purpose of strengthening the habit of civil and open discussion of controversial issues on campus. The controversies it arouses are often connected to anti-Semitism, other kinds of racism and exclusionary nationalism, and colonialism. To contribute to the objective, unbiased knowledge of Israel thus is not only of crucial importance in itself, but can help us understand these issues as such and the dynamics based on them in other societies. The course will use the American society as a constant back-drop, examining various aspects of Israeli society in comparison with similar problems in the USA. Comparisons will also be systematically made with Israel’s neighbors in the Middle East and, when appropriate, other societies in Europe and Asia. These thematic and comparative perspectives should make it of interest to numerous students across social sciences and the campus, in general.

Beginning with the question why Israel attracts so much international attention, the course will explore the circumstances in which the State of Israel was founded and developed, and the character, as well as the record, of Israel as a democracy relative to other democracies, in particular the US. We shall ask how does Israel measure to other societies as it regards individual freedom, equality, popular sovereignty, and human rights – values universally considered core to a democracy. Because of the ongoing debates in the United States on topics of racism and immigration, the discussion of these general issues will focus on the experiences of black and brown Israelis, and immigration and refugee issues in Israel. The specific questions to be discussed each week are listed in the syllabus below.

Due to the importance of current events, we shall pay particular attention to the reaction of the world to the pogrom of October 7, 2023, and the war it provoked. Within this framework, the class will be organized as a research seminar, with teams of students responsible for collection of data and presenting arguments and counter-arguments on specific subjects, such as comparative records of international bodies (UN), great powers (US, UK, USSR/Russia), Israel, and Israel’s neighbors regarding claims to territory; sovereignty; immigration, race, and ethnicity; religion, culture, and identity; diplomacy and warfare; human rights and refugee problems; antisemitism and racism; political process; economic development.

Specific research topics are listed in the syllabus below. Participants are required to declare their preferences (listing at least 2 topics in the presentation of which they would like to participate) during the second class of the semester. Topics will be assigned and students will be expected to work on their research from then on, bringing their findings into the class discussions as they progress. The last four weeks of the semester, as indicated below, will be devoted entirely to student presentations and discussions.

Much of the class material will be visual. The class will view documentaries, such as “The US and the Holocaust”; “Night Will Fall”; “Israel Inside: How a Small Nation Makes a Big Difference”; “Pillar of Fire”; “The Forgotten Refugees”; the 1947 film Gentlemen’s Agreement; and a selection of vlogs on YouTube. Some of these will be assigned for viewing at home. Students will be required to analyze and draw independent conclusions from these. In addition, the class will rely as much as possible on published primary sources, such as maps, historical documents, international statistics, and eyewitness testimony. Martin Gilbert’s Israel: A History and David Wyman, The Abandonment of the Jews: America and the Holocaust, 1941-1945 will serve as the background reading. Participants are encouraged to read these through at their own pace, making sure they finish the two books by week 7 of the class when they will be examined on it. Other texts are to be read for class or integrated in research assignments as needed.

Course objectives

The primary objective of the course is to teach students to think about any controversial subject independently, unswayed by prior biases and dominant trends in public opinion whatever they may be, to be able to question sources of information, analyze them for consistency, and ascertain which of them may be considered reliable and which not. Achieving this will improve the students’ research skills across social science and, as citizens, enable them to distinguish between fake and legitimate information. The second objective is to improve the students’ knowledge about a specific controversial subject – the most controversial society, Israel, making them able to approach it, and participate in a discussion about it objectively and on the basis of vetted facts. It is expected that some of the students, after taking the class, would choose Israel as a country of specialization in their further studies. Other objectives include improving the students’ understanding of a range of issues, central both for the social sciences and for the world today, such as the nature of democracy and the dynamics of nationalism, race, religion, and ethnicity; as well as training them in uses of comparison for the purposes of social science analysis. The last but not the least of the course’s objectives is to develop students’ ability for self-examination and deepen their self-knowledge.

Course Requirements and Grading:

Attendance and participation in class discussion will count for 30% of the grade and will be reflected through weekly memos. Each week students are asked to write two paragraphs on the week’s course materials and class discussion, focusing on what they’ve learned (how their original views have changed) and questions these materials and discussion have raised in their minds. Students will submit their weekly assignments to the Blackboard by the end (midnight) of Friday after each class.

Oral presentation of the two research projects will account for 15% each, the examination on Gilbert and Wyman on week 7 for 20%, and final memo “Reevaluating the Conflict” for the remaining 20%. Late submission of the final memo must be discussed with and approved by the professor. Students are expected to connect between readings, documents, documentaries/films, and materials presented in class and to raise questions regarding these materials and knowledge gained through work on chosen research topics. Collaboration between students working on the same research topic is necessary.

2024 research topics:

1 Jewish Identity, Duration; Historical and Geographical Origins, Statehood, Displacement

2 Palestinian Identity, Ethnic and Religious composition of populations called Palestinian

3 Nationalism and Democracy; Their Types; Zionism and Palestinian Nationalism

4 Modern Israel in Comparison to its neighbors and the USA: diversity, human rights

5 History and Context of the Foundation of the Modern Jewish State; Its Political Fallout

6 History of the UN; Its Focus on Israel; UNWRA

7 Displacement, Immigration, Refugees

8 Genocide: definition and examples; Geneva Conventions, International Law

Questions addressed and to be thought about throughout the semester:

Identities and nations. What makes a nation? What is a people? Nationalisms in the Middle East. Zionism and anti-Zionism: reasons for emergence, evolution, and formulation. Relation to antisemitism. Antisemitism and racism. Palestinian nationalism; Palestine vs. Syria. Human rights. Right of self-determination. Whose rights are these? Types of nationalism. Nationalism and Democracy. Religion, secularization, and ethnic identity. What is a native population? What establishes a population’s right to a land? What is colonialism? Who owned the land in the Middle East? How was the land acquired? What was the condition of the land? How were neighboring states formed? What makes a refugee? Today’s attitudes and policies: reasons for change. 1948 – 1967 and beyond. Middle East and refugees. Palestinian refugees. Why Palestinian refugees deserve special attention? The importance of nomenclature. Immigration absorption in Israel. Race and Ethnicity. What is a mass immigration? Israel as an immigrant society; US as a comparison. Racial diversity in Israel and the US.

Required readings:

Hussein Aboubakr, “The Perennial Power of the Nakba.” https://mosaicmagazine.com/essay/israel-zionism/2023/09/the-perennial-power-of-the-nakba/

Martin Gilbert. Israel: A History. 2008. Harper Perennial.

Liah Greenfeld. Advanced Introduction to Nationalism. 2016. Edward Elgar.

Walter Laqueur and Barry Rubin. The Israel-Arab Reader: A Documentary History of the

Middle East Conflict, 7th Edition. 2008. Penguin Books.

David Wyman, The Abandonment of the Jews: America and the Holocaust, 1941-1945. 2007. The New Press.

Commentaries, published in 2023:

Michael Oren, 10/31, “Why the Body Cams?”

Alex Safian, 10/31, “Water, Electricity, and Food in Gaza”

“How Hamas Won Hearts and Minds on the American Left”, 11/3.

Ronald Liebowitz, “How universities should confront antisemitism on campus,” Boston Globe, 11/6.

WSJ, 11/8, “China and Russia Claim Moral High Ground”

Melanie Phillips, 11/8, “How Israel Tries to Protect Gaza’s Civilians”

Horrifying Images NOT from Gaza, NYT, 11/2-11/12

WSJ, 11/12, Scenes of Genocide [a Muslim Doctor] Saw in Israeli Morgues

WSJ, 11/15, The Battle for Al Shifa Hospital

Red Cross Document, 1944

IDF, Mission Brief, 11/29

Commentary, 12/4, Israeli Arabs

An Exchange on Holocaust Memory https://www.nybooks.com/online/2023/12/08/an-exchange-on-holocaust-memory/

Michael Oren, 12/5, “The Ovens of Auschwitz Still Burn”

Melanie Phillips, 12/22, Christianity: “The Revival of an ancient calumny”

Melanie Phillips, 12/24, “The Failure of Holocaust education”

Comparing Hamas Massacre to Holocaust, Ingo Elbe and Enrico Pfau, Fathom Journal, December 2023.

Recommended Readings:

Alan Dershowitz. The Case for Israel. 2004. John Wiley & Sons, Inc.

Yair Gad and Orit Gazit (eds.). Collective Identities, States, and Globalization. 2010. Magnes.

George Gilder. The Israel Test. 2009. Richard Vigilante Books.

Giulio Meotti. A New Shoah: The Untold Story of Israel’s Victims of Terrorism. 2010. Encounter

Books.

Dan Senor and Saul Singer. Start-Up Nation: The Story of Israel’s Economic Miracle. 2011.

Twelve.

Ilan Troen and Rachel Fish (eds.). Essential Israel: Essays for the 21 st Century. 2017. Indiana

University Press.

Class Schedule:

Week 1, January 24: Introductory Session

The Current Conflict: The knowledge students bring to class about Israel, Jews,

Palestinians, Palestine, Hamas

Numbers of Jews in the world, in Israel. UN focus on Israel. UN focus on Palestine. UN budget;

UNWRA budget. Costs of conflicts in casualties and displaced persons (“Costs of War,” Watson

Institute). Achievements of Jews, of Israel. Antisemitism statistics. Maps of the Middle East.

Population and territory comparisons. Vital statistics. Ethnicity and Religion. Economy: Size and

Growth. Economy: Sectors. Economy: Exports and Imports. Episodes from “Israel Inside.”

Watch at home “The US and the Holocaust.” https://www.pbs.org/kenburns/us-and-the-holocaust/

Read: Use and Misuse of Holocaust Memory, https://www.nybooks.com/online/2023/12/08/an-exchange-on-holocaust-memory/

Comparing Hamas Massacre to Holocaust, Ingo Elbe and Enrico Pfau, Fathom Journal, December 2023.

Michael Oren, 12/5, “The Ovens of Auschwitz Still Burn”

Melanie Phillips, 12/24, “The Failure of Holocaust education”

Recommended Readings: Troen/Fish, “Israel in World’s Opinion”; “Israel: Geography,

Demography, and Economy.”

Week 2, January 31: Context (I): The Two Catastrophes

Reading for class: Hussein Aboubakr, “The Perennial Power of the Nakba”

Watching in class “Night Will Fall”

Webb, Why Are There Palestinian Refugees

Week 3, February 7: Context (II): Religious Considerations

Reading for class: Aboubakr II, “Hamas’s Messianic Violence”

The Hamas Charter

Michael Oren, “A War Against the Jews”

Dara Horn, The New York Times, “Why Jews Cannot Stop Shaking Right Now”

Melanie Phillips, 12/22, Christianity: “The Revival of an ancient calumny”

Watching at home: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w3NX4VnNuV8

Watching in class “The Bible’s Buried Secrets”

Week 4, February 14: Context (III) (Modern Political Expectations)

Watching Episode 1 of “Pillar of Fire”

History of Israel/Palestine Conflict https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tLv6u3kb-ds

UN Anti-Democratic Agenda https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nKHGoJe0njc

Reading: Nationalism: A Short History, pp. 1- 33; 85 – 115.

Zionism and the UN, Abba Eban, 1975

Recommended: Troen/Fish, “Israel: A Jewish Democracy”; “The Arab-Israeli Conflict”; “From

Zionism to Zion.”

Week 5 , February 28: Context IV (Psychological Considerations)

Watching “Gentleman’s Agreement” (Available on Amazon Prime)

“Why Are Holocaust Museums Cowering in Silence?” COMMENTARY, 11/6

Sexual Violence on October 7: NYT Investigation (12/28/2023)

WSJ, 11/12, Scenes of Genocide [a Muslim Doctor] Saw in Israeli Morgues

1/2/24 (10/26) Julia Steinberg, “Why My Generation Hates Jews”

Israeli Arab educates https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RlPegRjl1XU

On Steven Fry https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s_zXdpFIA-U

Week 6, March 6: Immigration and Refugees

Watching “Pillar of Fire” (Exodus episode)

“The Forgotten Refugees” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=54oYVnmkGhs

Read: https://www.timesofisrael.com/immigration-minister-arrives-in-ethiopia-to-airlift-500-jews-to-israel/

Recommended reading: Troen/Fish, “Citizenship and Democracy in Israel.”

Documents: Maps from Balfour Declaration to 1948. Presented in class: Documents of British

policies regarding refugees in Mandate Palestine. British policies regarding immigration (Arab

and Jewish) to Mandate Palestine. US and refugees, record of a century.

The formation of the State of Israel: UN Resolution; US position; Soviet position; Arab position.

Arab response to the Declaration of the State of Israel.

Week 7, March 20: Commentaries on the Current Conflict

First session of the class is devoted to the examination on Gilbert’s and Wyman’s texts.

Short readings:

Alex Safian, 10/31, “Water, Electricity, and Food in Gaza”

“How Hamas Won Hearts and Minds on the American Left”, 11/3.

Ronald Liebowitz, Boston Globe, 11/6.

WSJ, 11/8, “China and Russia Claim Moral High Ground”

Melanie Phillips, 11/8, “How Israel Tries to Protect Gaza’s Civilians”

Horrifying Images NOT from Gaza, NYT, 11/2-11/12

WSJ, 11/15, The Battle for Al Shifa Hospital

IDF, Mission Brief, 11/29

Commentary, 12/4, Israeli Arabs

On SJP, 12/22

Arab Blogger on Gaza, 12/25

Are social media and coordinated misinformation campaigns fomenting extremism, 12/21

Glen Loury, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bKOqsJTFl7k

Antisemitism https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ukd05G9ggb0

Hitler Knew How to deal with Jews https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3XBlGEU2GH8

Simon Webb, Facts about Gaza you are unlikely to see, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZlpUnNzFxr8

Mazi Melesa Pilip https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YgnGHDqfSok

Hamas Leader Needs Palestinians’ Blood https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NFDszL9Assw

Gaurav Aria, Nikki Haley https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RapNWUItZwA

Week 8, March 27: Antisemitism in the Middle East: 1920s—2020s.

Watching “Pillar of Fire”

Hadj-Amin Al Husseini – Nazism, WWII

Recommended: Troen/Fish, “Perceptions and Understanding of Israel within Islam.”

Week 9: April 3: Cultural Appropriation and Cultural Debt; The Origins of “the Oldest Hatred.” Lecture and general discussion

Weeks 10 (April 10), 11 (April 17), 12 (April 24), and 13 (May 1) are devoted to students’ research presentations and discussions.

Over the years Liah Greenfeld taught the course, the students’ reactions were largely positive—here’s one from 2018:

Over the course of my research, I was confronted with many personal biases I harbored. Prior to entering this class, I was convinced that anti-zionism was justified because it was not anti-semitism, but rather an aversion to further expansion by Israel. After all, Israel already existed. I thought, how could protecting the rights of Palestinians be anti-semitic?

However, my beliefs— as I argue in this essay about several political scientists— lacked historical context. Palestinians, unbeknownst to me, did not originally have control over the territory that is formally known as Israel today. In fact, Jews could be considered to be the “native peoples” of the land. My preconceptions, however, led me to believe that Jewish immigration to the middle east was forcing the natives— Palestinians— from the land.

Furthermore, I was unaware that Jewish immigrants settled in lands where Palestinians did not reside; primarily due to infertile lands that the Jewish immigrants were successfully able to cultivate. I was led to believe, by media sources and falsehoods that are spread throughout liberal communities, that the Israelis had forced the Palestinians from their land in a quest to obtain their own homeland.

My research has also led me to discover the numerous different meanings of Zionism. Among the Israelis, several different definitions of Zionism were adopted. Some believed that all of Palestinian territory should be theres while many others agreed that a two-state solution would suffice. This has forced me to confront the fact that “anti-zionists” lack a clear understanding of Israeli settlement and of personal attitudes.

Leave a Reply