Author Archives: gililiah

Twelve Theses on Antisemitism

Liah Greenfeld, Unguarded Thoughts, May 06, 2025

Complexity Made Simple.

Antisemitism is the attitude of Christian and Muslim populations considering themselves
essentially inferior to the Jews from whom they borrowed God and thus developing a permanent
complex of inferiority vis-à-vis the Jews, and existential envy and hatred towards them.

Thesis 1. Antisemitism is a late name for Jew-hate, hatred of Jews. It is, therefore, a sentiment
of hatred.
Thesis 2. This hatred applies to all Jews – to the Jews as a group: a religion, a race, a state;
individuals are hated not for their actions, but for what they are.
Thesis 3. Hating people for their identity, for what they are, regardless of particular actions of
particular individuals, allows the haters to hate absolutely innocent individuals such as babies
and little children.
Thesis 4. Hating people for their identity, for what they are, regardless of particular actions of
particular individuals, is irrational. Antisemitism is irrational.
Thesis 5. Antisemitism is 2000 years old. It is continuous irrational hatred of Jews. For 2000
years antisemitism expresses itself in discrimination, humiliation, and violence against Jewish
individuals (including babies) who are hated for what they are.
Thesis 6. Every expression of antisemitism in the course of 2000 years is presented as a rational
reaction, justified by some – different — actions of the Jews. Changing justifications (necessarily
particular, historically circumscribed actions of particular individuals) for the unchanging
sentiment (hatred of Jews as a group for what they are, including babies) in the course of 2000
years implies the falsehood of such justifications. Examples of false justifications: Christ-killing;
attempt to kill Muhammad; poisoning of wells; working on Sabbath, thereby offending God (in
the Quran); serving Mammon; being Communists; settler colonialism.
Thesis 7. Antisemitism is logically unjustifiable.
Thesis 8. Antisemitism – the irrational targeted hatred of the Jews as a group, lasting for 2000
years – is a unique phenomenon. No other population is a target for such hatred.
Thesis 9. All other instances of intergroup hostility are rational, historically circumscribed, and
can be explained by their historical context. Antisemitism cannot be explained historically.

Demonstrators in New York, Sept. 23, 2026

Thesis 10. Antisemitism is essentially a psychological phenomenon. The only historical context
relevant to the explanation of antisemitism is the context which produces the psychological
dynamic of the continuous irrational hatred of the Jews as a group.
Thesis 11. Antisemitism is explained by choosing Judaism as the model, attempting to imitate
the Jews in their monotheism, and borrowing the Jewish God. This happens independently
within the Roman Empire of the early centuries of the CE, leading to Christianity, and in the
Arabian Peninsula in the 7th century CE, leading to Islam. The independent rise of continuous
targeted hatred of the Jews as a group in two completely different historical contexts proves the
centrality of psychological factors.
Thesis 12. Choice of Judaism as the model implies that the Jews as a group are regarded by the
imitators as superior, and the imitators’ communities as inferior. The imitators’ inability to prove
to themselves that they succeeded to become like the Jews turns the temporary sense of
inferiority into the permanent psychologically destabilizing complex of inferiority. To escape it,
the imitators begin to regard the Jews as the anti-model, while their initial admiration of the
Jews transforms into an existential envy and hatred.

More here

American Journal of Psychiatry Review of Greenfeld’s Mind, Modernity, Madness

Liah Greenfeld, Mind, Modernity, Madness: The Impact of Culture on Human Experience

Reviewed by Joseph Westermeyer, M.D., M.P.H., Ph.D.

Am J Psychiatry 2014;171:231-232. doi:10.1176/appi.ajp.2013.13091242

https://psychiatryonline.org/doi/10.1176/appi.ajp.2013.13091242

Is our culture, with one-fourth of adults mentally ill, devastating itself? Greenfeld contends that it is.

The suicidal course of our species began when the emerging human larynx and brain facilitated speech 20,000 to 30,000 years ago. This transformation enabled a radical progression from articulating signs (an animal capacity) to articulating symbols. Unlike signs, symbols represented phenomena of which they were not part. Symbolic thinking begat the mind, com-posed of the brain plus ideas gleaned from culturally created environments. Minds became “individualized culture.”

Symbolic thought has yielded both boon and burden for the human species and its emerging mind. Logic and observation, the origins of science, comprise thought forms permitting contradiction. Much symbolic thinking consists of abstractions not liable to contradiction (e.g., shared religious and political beliefs, cultural norms and values) or liable to contradiction only if reduced to stark numbers. Symbolic thoughts, coalesced into systems, show varying consistency and thus are not wholly logical, coherent, or liable to contradiction. For better and worse, symbolic thinking can change suddenly, produce indecision arising from its own incongruities, and even veer from reality. Within the mind’s capacity for symbolism exist the seeds for disabling “madness” or “insanity.”

Continue reading →

Liah Greenfeld and Civilizational Dialogue: For Continuing a Legacy

Manindra Nath Thakur, Jawaharlal Nehru University

One fine morning, I dropped into my room at the Centre for Political Studies, JNU.
Monika took an appointment to meet and discuss her project. I was curious to know
about her work and wanted to see if there was anything to learn from it. Within no time,
I discovered that she was influenced by a professor and that we had many common
concerns. I listened carefully and was convinced by her impression. We decided to
initiate a conversation. Suddenly, a few months later, she informed me about Liah
Greenfeld’s sad demise. Our conversation could not take off.

There are some scholars whom you meet and never forget. There are others whom one
never gets an opportunity to meet, yet whose ideas enter one’s intellectual world with
such intensity that they become part of the future conversations in absentia. Professor
Liah Greenfeld belongs to the latter category for me. Monika shared some of her
writings, and I discovered striking convergences between her work and the questions a
group of us in India has been pursuing in the Creative Theory Colloquium. We had
begun contemplating a larger civilizational conversation that could bring together
different intellectual traditions and modes of understanding humanity.

The news of her passing away came as a blow to our plans. However, some
conversations do not end with death. Indeed, the most significant conversations in
human history often begin after the physical departure of those who initiate them. If
civilization itself is a cumulative dialogue across generations, then the death of a thinker
does not close a discussion. In this case, I believe, it should begin the discussion. The
shift of location is inevitable — from direct exchange to engagement through texts,
ideas, memoirs, and communities of scholars. Despite not being able to converse with
her directly, I felt it was worth documenting her influence on our thinking to initiate a
new chapter in the dialogue. I would like to acknowledge her presence in the memory
of the members of the Creative Theory Group who enjoy discussing her writings.

Civilizational Dialogue and Emergentist Universals

What first attracted me to Greenfeld’s work was her attempt to recover the concept of
civilization as a serious analytical category. For several decades, the language of
civilization has often been viewed with suspicion. It was associated either with
triumphalist narratives of the West or with simplistic theories of cultural conflict.
Greenfeld approached the idea differently. Instead of ranking civilizations, it invited
us to address the question of differences in civilization. It is no longer a question of judging a civilization as good or bad. She appreciated the differences in civilizations and suggested exploring the reasons for these differences and developing a theory to understand them.

Continue reading →

Following Through Dialogues: A Chinese Scholar’s Reminiscence of Professor Liah Greenfeld

By Xinqi Jia, Beijing Normal University

Ordinarily, a Chinese teacher of ethics who had never set foot in a Western country
before the age of forty and a Jewish-American sociologist born in the former Soviet
Union would have no reason to cross paths. Yet, throughout 2010, they spent an entire
year in Boston in close contact. Should anyone someday write a biography of the late
Professor Liah Greenfeld, this story alone would be excellent material for exploring
how her theory has influenced the world, and how, as an outstanding theorist, she
continually expanded the boundaries of our understanding of it.

Studying ethics
One afternoon in January 2010, Professor Liah Greenfeld stepped out of her office on
the sixth floor of the School of Theology at Boston University and stood in the hallway
to welcome a visiting scholar from China — that is, me. Only a few months earlier, I
had received a grant that allowed me to study abroad for a year as a visiting scholar. I
contacted Professor Greenfeld and quickly received a positive reply. It might have
seemed odd because Professor Greenfeld is a sociologist, while my specialty is
philosophy — more precisely, ethics, and mainly the history of Chinese ethical thought.
But to me, it made perfect sense.

Depiction of the The “Five Relationships”: ruler to ruled, father to son, husband to wife, elder brother to younger brother, and friend to friend https://chiculture.org.hk/en/china-five-thousand-years/4088

It is well known that ethics studies morality, and one of its important aims is to respond
to real-world problems such as social justice, ecological degradation, and spiritual crises
from a moral perspective. Among ethicists, two views are common: first, that moral
issues can be separated from the social system and treated as independent phenomena
— and even when the relationship between morality and other social factors is
acknowledged, the understanding is often very superficial; second, that morality is
something constant, and accordingly, one should seek quick fixes to real-world
problems. These are non-systematic and ahistorical views.

In my opinion, ethicists trapped in such misconceptions, even if they occasionally
produce seemingly profound and subtle philosophical insights, are of little real help in
solving problems such as social justice, environmental degradation, and spiritual crises.
I lean toward a different approach: morality is only one element within the social
system. Only by first understanding its relationship with the social system can we know
what we can do with it and how. At the same time, the social system itself evolves from
tradition to modernity to the future. Only by understanding this process can we grasp
the essence of modern society and the roots of its problems — and their solutions.

Around 2005, I happened to buy a book from a bookstore ⎯ that was Professor
Greenfeld’s The Spirit of Capitalism: Nationalism and Economic Growth, which had
just been translated into Chinese. Frankly, I have read many books, but few have
resonated with me as strongly as this one, because its theoretical perspective aligned so
well with my own. Even now, I consider it Professor Greenfeld’s finest work (after
2009, I read some of her other books). It left such a deep impression on me that, years
later, when I was looking for a mentor as a visiting scholar, her name came to mind
immediately.

Continue reading →

Liah Greenfeld on Antisemitism as a Defining Characteristic of the Monotheistic Civilization

By Efraim Karsh, King’s College, London and Bar-Ilan University, Israel

One cannot overstate the scholarly and intellectual loss occasioned by the untimely death of Boston University Professor Liah Greenfeld. Through her prodigious interdisciplinary research, Professor Greenfeld has established herself as one of the foremost social science theorists of our time and a worthy heir to the great first-generation nationalism scholars, in particular Eric Hobsbawm, Ernest Gellner, and Anthony Smith.

Best known for her seminal trilogy on nationalism — Nationalism: Five Roads to Modernity (Harvard University Press, 1992); The Spirit of Capitalism: Nationalism and Economic Growth (Harvard University Press, 2001); and Mind, Modernity, Madness: The Impact of Culture on Human Experience (Harvard University Press, 2013) — Greenfeld’s studies have spanned the entire range of human social activity, from art, to literature, to science, to religion, to love, to ideological politics, among other dimensions. She has been called “the great historian of nationalism,” “the most iconoclastic” of contemporary sociologists, and “a paradigm changer in the understanding of economic growth.” The eminent social scientist Charles Tilly lauded her for offering the only serious alternative to the mainstream approach in the social sciences, of which he was a foremost proponent.

Already in the trilogy’s first book, Greenfeld turned the conventional understanding of both nationalism and modernity on its head. Rejecting the conventional characterization of nationalism as the cultural byproduct of modern economic development, specifically capitalism, which also brought about the modern state, she defined this phenomenon as the form of consciousness formed around the core idea of social reality by sovereign communities of fundamentally equal members and shared identity, thus showing how this symbolic, cultural phenomenon led to other characteristics of modernity. This in turn made nationalism the cause of modernity rather than its corollary. And by way of proving this revolutionary thesis, Greenfeld traced the advent and evolution of nationalism in the five societies that were historically the first to define and organize themselves as nations (while also being the major players in world politics) — England/Britain, France, Russia, Germany, and the United States.

Unlike Five Roads’ predominantly political focus, the trilogy’s second volume — The Spirit of Capitalism — explores the economic foundations of nationalism in the above countries, with Japan and the Netherlands, which played a longtime key international economic role, substituting for Russia. It shows that a growth-driven modern economic orientation (“the spirit of capitalism,” to use Max Weber’s words) followed the advent of nationalism, and that wherever nationalism failed to emerge (as in the extremely important Dutch counter-case), a growth-oriented capitalist economy failed to develop even when all the conventionally postulated conditions existed. This was due to the necessarily endless competition for national dignity — the standing of one’s nation among others — in which any walk of life (from literature, to science, to the military, to women’s beauty) was a potential arena for international competition; and whenever the economy became such an arena, this led to the economy of growth.

But the story does not end here. While researching the above case studies, Greenfeld realized that Japanese nationalism was far less prone than its Western counterparts (Russia in particular) to profound feelings of inferiority and envy. The only exception to this rule was England/Britain, which, as a pioneer of both nationalism and the economy of growth, was the object of existential envy and hatred, or ressentiment — a concept developed by Greenfeld following Nietzsche and Scheller.1 This observation, in turn, led to the highly ambitious exploration in the trilogy’s final volume of the interrelationship between nationalism, modernity, and culture in general, and of the paradoxical association between liberal democracy’s undeniable fruits and the prevalence of mental illness in Western societies, in particular.

Based on meticulous comparative analysis, Greenfeld concluded that rates of functional mental illness were characteristic of societies rather than individuals, hence owed their causation at the very least to historical and sociological factors. Specifically, in all examined case studies, such major psychiatric diseases as manic depression and schizophrenia became a public health problem in tandem with the advent of nationalism. This was the case in 16th-century England, followed in the 17th century by other parts of Britain, including the American colonies, and by continental Europe in the late 18th-early 19th centuries.

Greenfeld ascribes this sociohistorical phenomenon to nationalism’s substitution of popular will for God as the source of sovereignty, which in turn has transformed the individual into one’s own maker and has made the formation of personal identity a matter of personal choice and responsibility. The larger the number of proffered options, the more difficult such choice—and, in consequence, the formation of personal identity within nations. Predicated on a democratic, egalitarian, and essentially secular consciousness, nations became anomic, confused, and confusing societies.

Their anomie was the cultural agent of the mental illness whose core symptoms, problematic sense of self and social maladjustment, reflected malformed personal identity. The more choices society offered to a greater number of its members (i.e., the more it insisted on equality and freedom of choice), the higher the rates of functional mental illness in it became as people vied with constant appraisal of their identities, management of their desires, and calibration of their place within society.

There remained one problem: how to account for the marked differences between the psychiatric profiles of Western and South-East Asian nations. In Greenfeld’s concluding words of Mind, Modernity, Madness:

“Why don’t the orienting principles of nationalism disorient the Orient? Would monotheism and logic have anything to do with this? Could the root of the problem (not its cause, perhaps, but a necessary condition) lie deeper than nationalism, reaching to the very foundation of our civilization?”2

This civilizational divide extends, of course, way beyond different national psychiatric profiles to numerous divergencies in modes of thought, fundamental values and belief systems, political cultures, and psychological dynamics, among others (“East is East and West is West, and never the twain shall meet,” Rudyard Kipling famously rhapsodized). One of these, with which Greenfeld had intimate knowledge from a young age, was the millenarian anti-Jewish bigotry in Christian and Muslim societies, or antisemitism as it came to be known in modern times, which was glaringly missing from the two great eastern civilizations — Chinese and Indian.3

Continue reading →

Reflection on Liah Greenfeld’s Influence on My Work: National Consciousness and the Sociological Imagination

By Oliver Benoit, PhD, MFA, School of Arts and Sciences, St. George’s University, Grenada

Few scholars have influenced my intellectual development as much as Liah Greenfeld. While my academic interests emerged from an attempt to understand the Grenada Revolution and its collapse in 1983, it was Greenfeld’s work that provided clarity to the questions I asked and the conceptual tools I employed to answer the question: What caused the collapse of the Grenada Revolution? Her scholarship redirected my attention away from conventional explanations rooted exclusively in economics, ideology, or political institutions and toward the cultural foundations of modernity itself. More specifically, Greenfeld’s theory of nationalism provided a framework through which I came to embrace a better understanding of the Grenadian experience as well as the broader challenges of postcolonial development, nation formation, and political culture.

My encounter with Greenfeld occurred during my graduate studies at Brandeis University. At the time, I remained preoccupied with a question that had occupied my mind since the collapse of the Grenada Revolution: why had a political movement that promised dignity, equality, self-reliance, and national renewal ended in tragedy? Existing explanations seemed inadequate. Marxist analyses emphasized class conflict and imperialism; political scientists focused on leadership struggles and institutional weaknesses; historians highlighted Cold War dynamics and external intervention. While each perspective contributed valuable insights, none seemed able to explain the deeper social and cultural dimensions of the crisis. What appeared to be missing was an understanding of how people construct collective identities, how they attach meaning to political projects, and how aspirations for dignity, respect, and equality become embedded in social life.

Greenfeld’s work supplied precisely that missing dimension I believed has been central to the Grenada question. Her contribution to sociology lies in her insistence that modernity is fundamentally a cultural phenomenon. Contrary to approaches that define modernity primarily in terms of industrialization, capitalism, bureaucratization, or technological advancement, Greenfeld argues that the defining characteristic of modernity is the emergence of nationalism. Nationalism, from her perspective, is not merely a political ideology or an expression of patriotism; it is a form of consciousness that redefines society as a sovereign community composed of fundamentally equal individuals. Through nationalism, individuals come to understand themselves as members of a nation and therefore as bearers of dignity.

Continue reading →

Memorial Event for Liah Greenfeld, September 1, 2026

Speakers in order of appearance: Mark Simes, Francesco Duina, Michael Arellano, David Barron, Edward Gormbley, Jonathan Eastwood, Peter Baehr, Chandler Rosenberger, James Stergios.

Text of Memorial Lecture:

Unconventionality in Greenfeld’s Thought

Francesco Duina

Charles A. Dana Professor of Sociology and European Studies
Bates College (USA)

Liah Greenfeld Memorial Lecture

Boston University

Sep 1, 2026

Hello everyone. 

Thank you, Gil, for asking me to share my reflections on Liah, her work, and how consequential that work has been for me and – I am sure – for everyone else who is here, is following online, or is simply one of the many thousands who have read her work, listened to her lectures, or have been exposed to her thinking in some other way.

And thank you, Mark, for managing this event. It’s very good to be here, together.

I will do something that is a bit unusual for me – I will read my remarks. I just want to ensure that I say with some precision what I wish to share.

We are all here because of what Liah meant to us. We are here to honor her as a mentor, a passionate thinker, a major reference point in our own ways of looking at the world, a collaborator (for some of us), and a friend. Some of us met her only recently. Others were lucky to meet her a long time ago. I, for one, met her in the fall of 1991. She was the classical sociological theory professor in my first year of the PhD program at Harvard. Regardless of how long we may have known her, all of us – if I may speak on behalf of everyone – hold her in a particular place in our minds and hearts.

Continue reading →

Special CCR Issue Dedicated to Liah Greenfeld

Comparative Civilizations Review, No. 95, 2026

https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/ccr/vol95/iss95/24

Table of Contents

Guest Editor’s Introduction ¾ Liah Greenfeld and the Future of Comparative Civilizational Studies

Monika………………………………………………………………….. 1

Liah Greenfeld: A Reflection from the President of the Comparative Civilizations Forum

Bibi Pelić……………………………………………………………….. 7

From the Editor-in-Chief ¾ Liah Greenfeld: Scholar, Thinker, Friend

Joseph Drew…………………………………………………………… 9

Applying Liah Greenfeld’s Comparative Civilizations Framework

Introduction to Liah Greenfeld’s Scholarship on Nationalism, Civilizations, and Humanity

Zeying Wu……………………………………………………………. 12

Towards the Systematic Cross-Civilizational Comparison: How Civilizations Work Case 3: The Chinese Case

Tiantian Wu………………………………………………………….. 24

A Historical Inquiry into the CPC’s Century-Long Evaluation of Confucianism and Its Return to the “Great Unity” Cultural Tradition

Ye Liu………………………………………………………………….. 51

The First Principles of Chinese Civilization: Relationalism and Pragmatism

Sai Zhang and Yongnian Zheng………………………………. 80

Temporal Legitimacy and Civilizational Logic: A Sociological Perspective on the Foundational Principles of Chinese Civilization

Yuk Man Cheung…………………………………………………. 111

Cognitive Foundations of the Absence of Antisemitism in Japan: Towards A Civilizational Perspective

Chikako Takeishi…………………………………………………. 130

Children’s Literature as a Site of Cross-Civilizational Analysis: Hong Kong in Crisis after 2019

Faye Dorcas Yung Schwendeman………………………….. 150

The “Original Spirit” of Chinese Civilization: Wang Huning and the Indigenization of Reform in Post-Mao China

Chandler Rosenberger………………………………………….. 166

The Concept of a ‘State-Civilization’ in Russia: The Contest for National Dignity in the Form of a Civilizational Analysis

Ivan Nokhrin……………………………………………………….. 176

Shifting Faith Among Indigenous People in Arunachal Pradesh, India: Revisiting Greenfeld’s Civilizational Framework

M. Amin Khan……………………………………………………………………………… 185

The Family as a Mechanism of Civilizational Continuity: Absorption, Localization, and Rejection of Modern Values in the Indic Case

Monika……………………………………………………………………………… 200

Reflections on Liah Greenfeld’s Scholarship

Liah Greenfeld and Civilizational Dialogue: For Continuing a Legacy

Manindra Nath Thakur……………………………………………………………………………… 214

Reflection on Liah Greenfeld’s Influence on My Work: National Consciousness and the Sociological Imagination

Oliver Benoit……………………………………………………………………………… 219

Unconventionality in Liah Greenfeld’s Thought

Francesco Duina……………………………………………………………………………………………. 223

Following Through Dialogues: A Chinese Scholar’s Reminiscence of Professor Liah Greenfeld

Xinqi Jia……………………………………………………………………………… 229

Liah Greenfeld on Antisemitism as a Defining Characteristic of the Monotheistic Civilization

Efraim Karsh……………………………………………………………………………… 235

Was Love Invented in Sixteenth-Century England? A Few Comments on Liah Greenfeld’s Theory of Emotions

Dmitri Panchenko……………………………………………………………………………… 243

Greenfeld’s Unpublished Lecture Notes

Professor Greenfeld’s Last Class: Notes for online lectures on “The Science of Humanity,” delivered to students and scholars primarily from India, July 2025

Liah Greenfeld……………………………………………………………………………… 249

President of Indonesia Quoting Liah Greenfeld

Antara Logo

Jakarta (ANTARA) – President Prabowo Subianto emphasized that lasting economic growth depends on strong support mechanisms and mutual commitment from all elements of the country to nationalism.

“The nature of modern economy is that it does not progress or develop on its own. Growth is stimulated and sustained by nationalism,” Subianto said, while quoting the economic theory of sociologist Professor Liah Greenfeld, in Bandar Lampung, Lampung, on Wednesday.

President Subianto made the statement at the 18th National Conference of the Indonesian Young Entrepreneurs Association (HIPMI).

According to him, such principle has been adopted by countries with major economic powers. He cited the historical examples of the economic revival of Japan, the United States, Western Europe, and China, attributing their success to a strong foundation of nationalism.

See original article

Obituary: When Ideas Still Mattered

By Tim Orr

Liah Greenfeld’s death genuinely saddened me. While I did not know her well, we spoke every year at the Association for the Study of the Middle East and Africa conference in Washington, DC. We often ended up sitting together at breakfast before the conference sessions started, talking about politics, religion, nationalism, Islam, and whatever else happened to come up. What always struck me about her was how approachable and intellectually curious she was. Here was a world-renowned scholar and distinguished professor at Boston University, yet she never carried herself with the kind of arrogance that sometimes exists in academic circles.

I always thought that was a breath of fresh air because it’s so easy for the academic world to get wrapped up in showing off who’s more accomplished, instead of being about learning, listening, and figuring out what’s true. It wasn’t like that with Greenfeld. She had a way of being genuinely interested when she talked to people, even with someone like me who was far less accomplished academically. That really stuck with me. There was a humility about her that made conversations with her feel relaxed and natural. And maybe, looking back, it also was something that made her scholarly work so innovative and influential. People who remain open continue to see things that others do not.

Her influence on the study of nationalism was enormous. Her book Nationalism: Five Roads to Modernity, helped reshape how many scholars understood nationalism and modern identity. Greenfeld argued that nationalism was not simply extremism or tribal politics, but one of the major forces shaping the modern world itself. She connected it to democracy, economics, culture, identity, and even psychology. Later works like Mind, Modernity, Madness: The Impact of Culture on Human Experience explored how culture and systems of meaning shape human experience and mental life. What made her work stand out was that she was willing to ask large civilizational questions at a time when much of academia was becoming increasingly narrow and specialized.

See original article