Tag Archives: Tributes

Liah Greenfeld and Civilizational Dialogue: For Continuing a Legacy

Manindra Nath Thakur, Jawaharlal Nehru University

One fine morning, I dropped into my room at the Centre for Political Studies, JNU.
Monika took an appointment to meet and discuss her project. I was curious to know
about her work and wanted to see if there was anything to learn from it. Within no time,
I discovered that she was influenced by a professor and that we had many common
concerns. I listened carefully and was convinced by her impression. We decided to
initiate a conversation. Suddenly, a few months later, she informed me about Liah
Greenfeld’s sad demise. Our conversation could not take off.

There are some scholars whom you meet and never forget. There are others whom one
never gets an opportunity to meet, yet whose ideas enter one’s intellectual world with
such intensity that they become part of the future conversations in absentia. Professor
Liah Greenfeld belongs to the latter category for me. Monika shared some of her
writings, and I discovered striking convergences between her work and the questions a
group of us in India has been pursuing in the Creative Theory Colloquium. We had
begun contemplating a larger civilizational conversation that could bring together
different intellectual traditions and modes of understanding humanity.

The news of her passing away came as a blow to our plans. However, some
conversations do not end with death. Indeed, the most significant conversations in
human history often begin after the physical departure of those who initiate them. If
civilization itself is a cumulative dialogue across generations, then the death of a thinker
does not close a discussion. In this case, I believe, it should begin the discussion. The
shift of location is inevitable — from direct exchange to engagement through texts,
ideas, memoirs, and communities of scholars. Despite not being able to converse with
her directly, I felt it was worth documenting her influence on our thinking to initiate a
new chapter in the dialogue. I would like to acknowledge her presence in the memory
of the members of the Creative Theory Group who enjoy discussing her writings.

Civilizational Dialogue and Emergentist Universals

What first attracted me to Greenfeld’s work was her attempt to recover the concept of
civilization as a serious analytical category. For several decades, the language of
civilization has often been viewed with suspicion. It was associated either with
triumphalist narratives of the West or with simplistic theories of cultural conflict.
Greenfeld approached the idea differently. Instead of ranking civilizations, it invited
us to address the question of differences in civilization. It is no longer a question of judging a civilization as good or bad. She appreciated the differences in civilizations and suggested exploring the reasons for these differences and developing a theory to understand them.

Continue reading →

Following Through Dialogues: A Chinese Scholar’s Reminiscence of Professor Liah Greenfeld

By Xinqi Jia, Beijing Normal University

Ordinarily, a Chinese teacher of ethics who had never set foot in a Western country
before the age of forty and a Jewish-American sociologist born in the former Soviet
Union would have no reason to cross paths. Yet, throughout 2010, they spent an entire
year in Boston in close contact. Should anyone someday write a biography of the late
Professor Liah Greenfeld, this story alone would be excellent material for exploring
how her theory has influenced the world, and how, as an outstanding theorist, she
continually expanded the boundaries of our understanding of it.

Studying ethics
One afternoon in January 2010, Professor Liah Greenfeld stepped out of her office on
the sixth floor of the School of Theology at Boston University and stood in the hallway
to welcome a visiting scholar from China — that is, me. Only a few months earlier, I
had received a grant that allowed me to study abroad for a year as a visiting scholar. I
contacted Professor Greenfeld and quickly received a positive reply. It might have
seemed odd because Professor Greenfeld is a sociologist, while my specialty is
philosophy — more precisely, ethics, and mainly the history of Chinese ethical thought.
But to me, it made perfect sense.

Depiction of the The “Five Relationships”: ruler to ruled, father to son, husband to wife, elder brother to younger brother, and friend to friend https://chiculture.org.hk/en/china-five-thousand-years/4088

It is well known that ethics studies morality, and one of its important aims is to respond
to real-world problems such as social justice, ecological degradation, and spiritual crises
from a moral perspective. Among ethicists, two views are common: first, that moral
issues can be separated from the social system and treated as independent phenomena
— and even when the relationship between morality and other social factors is
acknowledged, the understanding is often very superficial; second, that morality is
something constant, and accordingly, one should seek quick fixes to real-world
problems. These are non-systematic and ahistorical views.

In my opinion, ethicists trapped in such misconceptions, even if they occasionally
produce seemingly profound and subtle philosophical insights, are of little real help in
solving problems such as social justice, environmental degradation, and spiritual crises.
I lean toward a different approach: morality is only one element within the social
system. Only by first understanding its relationship with the social system can we know
what we can do with it and how. At the same time, the social system itself evolves from
tradition to modernity to the future. Only by understanding this process can we grasp
the essence of modern society and the roots of its problems — and their solutions.

Around 2005, I happened to buy a book from a bookstore ⎯ that was Professor
Greenfeld’s The Spirit of Capitalism: Nationalism and Economic Growth, which had
just been translated into Chinese. Frankly, I have read many books, but few have
resonated with me as strongly as this one, because its theoretical perspective aligned so
well with my own. Even now, I consider it Professor Greenfeld’s finest work (after
2009, I read some of her other books). It left such a deep impression on me that, years
later, when I was looking for a mentor as a visiting scholar, her name came to mind
immediately.

Continue reading →