Tag Archives: Antisemitism

Twelve Theses on Antisemitism

Liah Greenfeld, Unguarded Thoughts, May 06, 2025

Complexity Made Simple.

Antisemitism is the attitude of Christian and Muslim populations considering themselves
essentially inferior to the Jews from whom they borrowed God and thus developing a permanent
complex of inferiority vis-à-vis the Jews, and existential envy and hatred towards them.

Thesis 1. Antisemitism is a late name for Jew-hate, hatred of Jews. It is, therefore, a sentiment
of hatred.
Thesis 2. This hatred applies to all Jews – to the Jews as a group: a religion, a race, a state;
individuals are hated not for their actions, but for what they are.
Thesis 3. Hating people for their identity, for what they are, regardless of particular actions of
particular individuals, allows the haters to hate absolutely innocent individuals such as babies
and little children.
Thesis 4. Hating people for their identity, for what they are, regardless of particular actions of
particular individuals, is irrational. Antisemitism is irrational.
Thesis 5. Antisemitism is 2000 years old. It is continuous irrational hatred of Jews. For 2000
years antisemitism expresses itself in discrimination, humiliation, and violence against Jewish
individuals (including babies) who are hated for what they are.
Thesis 6. Every expression of antisemitism in the course of 2000 years is presented as a rational
reaction, justified by some – different — actions of the Jews. Changing justifications (necessarily
particular, historically circumscribed actions of particular individuals) for the unchanging
sentiment (hatred of Jews as a group for what they are, including babies) in the course of 2000
years implies the falsehood of such justifications. Examples of false justifications: Christ-killing;
attempt to kill Muhammad; poisoning of wells; working on Sabbath, thereby offending God (in
the Quran); serving Mammon; being Communists; settler colonialism.
Thesis 7. Antisemitism is logically unjustifiable.
Thesis 8. Antisemitism – the irrational targeted hatred of the Jews as a group, lasting for 2000
years – is a unique phenomenon. No other population is a target for such hatred.
Thesis 9. All other instances of intergroup hostility are rational, historically circumscribed, and
can be explained by their historical context. Antisemitism cannot be explained historically.

Demonstrators in New York, Sept. 23, 2026

Thesis 10. Antisemitism is essentially a psychological phenomenon. The only historical context
relevant to the explanation of antisemitism is the context which produces the psychological
dynamic of the continuous irrational hatred of the Jews as a group.
Thesis 11. Antisemitism is explained by choosing Judaism as the model, attempting to imitate
the Jews in their monotheism, and borrowing the Jewish God. This happens independently
within the Roman Empire of the early centuries of the CE, leading to Christianity, and in the
Arabian Peninsula in the 7th century CE, leading to Islam. The independent rise of continuous
targeted hatred of the Jews as a group in two completely different historical contexts proves the
centrality of psychological factors.
Thesis 12. Choice of Judaism as the model implies that the Jews as a group are regarded by the
imitators as superior, and the imitators’ communities as inferior. The imitators’ inability to prove
to themselves that they succeeded to become like the Jews turns the temporary sense of
inferiority into the permanent psychologically destabilizing complex of inferiority. To escape it,
the imitators begin to regard the Jews as the anti-model, while their initial admiration of the
Jews transforms into an existential envy and hatred.

More here